Q431 : Does Church Discipline require Church Membership?

Home  •  Questions  •  Subscribe  •  Previous  •  Next

AUDIO
VIDEO
Q431 : Does Church Discipline require Church Membership?

[This question is related to issues I discuss in my article Authority Inversion: The Subversion of Pastoral Leadershipa and related Q/A: Problems with Church Membership.b]

I'm interested in how you apply Matthew 18:15–17 and 1 Corinthians 5:12–13 if there is no formal membership?


A431 : by Tony Garland

Church Discipline

Passages which you’ve mentioned—concerning church discipline—are frequently held up as evidence of the need for formal church membership.1

15 “Moreover if your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault between you and him alone. If he hears you, you have gained your brother. 16 But if he will not hear, take with you one or two more, that ‘by the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.’ 17 And if he refuses to hear them, tell it to the church. But if he refuses even to hear the church, let him be to you like a heathen and a tax collector. (Matthew 18:15-17)

11 But now I have written to you not to keep company with anyone named a brother, who is sexually immoral, or covetous, or an idolater, or a reviler, or a drunkard, or an extortioner—not even to eat with such a person. 12 For what have I to do with judging those also who are outside? Do you not judge those who are inside? 13 But those who are outside God judges. Therefore “put away from yourselves the evil person.” (1 Corinthians 5:11-13)

Unless someone has agreed to formally join your church—the reasoning goes—how can you enforce church discipline since individuals haven’t agreed—formally, on paper—to subject themselves to the authority of the elders?

Also: should church discipline reach the stage where the individual refuses counsel and the need arises to “tell it to the church” or “put away from yourselves the evil person,” how could such an action be enforced? Isn’t a church service open for all to attend as a public space?

Churches and Private Property

Although church services are generally open to the public, they are usually situated on private property, in which case they are legally permitted to bar an individual from attending services, even if that person is quiet and not disruptive.2

If an individual, for whatever reason, is informed that they are no longer welcome and they refuse to leave, they can be considered a trespasser and removed by law enforcement.

The first amendment protects individuals from government interference, but it does not grant a right to "freedom of movement" or "freedom of worship" on private property without the owner's permission.

Thus, nothing prevents the enforcement of church discipline as described by the New Testament—whether a person is a formal member or not.

Non-Members in Attendance

From a practical point of view, even churches which encourage formal membership will have people in attendance who are not members. Some may be new to the church and unsure whether they will join. Others, such as this writer, remain unconvinced formal church membership is unambiguously taught in the New Testament.

Situations may arise where church discipline must be applied to non-members. In light of the above, that should not pose a problem since the issue of access to private property (whether the church building or homes of those who attend the fellowship) remains a revocable privilege—regardless of membership status.

Home Churches in the New Testament

One thing is clear, many early churches met within private homes (Rom. 16:5; 1Cor. 16:19; Col. 4:15; Phm. 1:2). It is unconvincing to argue that these informal assemblies had formal paperwork which those being added to the church were required to sign to be considered part of the group and fully participate in the local assembly.

I’ve heard numerous arguments (and read many articles) championing the necessity of formal church membership, but I'm unaware of clear scriptural evidence this is taught within the New Testament. The best case that can be made is based on inference—typically interpreting informal practices in the early church to imply formal membership must have been practiced.

I remain unconvinced.

If formal church membership was an important aspect of fellowship in New Testament times, then we should find clear mention and instruction pertaining to it. We do not.

Apart from the New Testament, some argue that formal church membership offers the potential of additional legal protection in the event church discipline results in a lawsuit initiated by the disciplined party.3

They prefer additional legal protection beyond the protection already afforded by the church autonomy doctrine. Still, it provides no added protection in situations involving non-members—a sizable portion of those attending many congregations.

The intersection of New Testament teaching and pragmatic business and legal practices is something each church will have to tackle on an individual basis. But it behooves us to carefully consider where the practices of modern society may compromise or undermine clear New Testament teaching—such as elder rule and the unity of the body of Christ.

Wherever that leads, it seems disingenuous to argue for formal church membership by appealing to weak inferences from the New Testament when the actual motive may have more to do with concerns with our litigious modern society.

Disclaimer - Not Legal Advice

⚠️ Speaking of liability: since I am not trained in legal matters,a nothing in this answer should be construed as legal advice. 😉


Endnotes:

1.“Those who are outside” (1Cor. 5:13) is contrasted with "anyone named a brother" (1Cor. 5:11) and therefor refers to unbelievers rather than non-members. The dividing line between those subject to church discipline or not is belief, not membership. Faith in Christ is the sole prerequisite for full participation in a local assembly.
2.Is a Church a Public Place or Private Property?,b published 2026-04-01, accessed 2026-11-14.
3.Christian Law Association,c 9marks.orgd


Search Website
Related Topics
AUDIO
VIDEO


Home  •  Questions  •  Subscribe  •  Previous  •  Next


Copyright © 2026 by www.SpiritAndTruth.org
(Content generated on Mon Nov 16 16:59:35 2026)
Contact